[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: [leafnode-list] only_groups_pcre and crossposting



* Matthias Andree <matthias.andree@xxxxxx> [2004-03-16 11:54 +0100]:
> Joshua Crawford schrieb am 2004-03-16:
> 
> > So, just checking I understand what you said, with the first article,
> > alt.fan.robert-jordan exists on Individual, so fetchnews attempts to post it
> > and it gets rejected because of the crosspost, whereas with the other, with
> > the binaries group first, it isn't even attempted because of the pcre?
> 
> That's the bug you are reporting and that I have finally seen a few
> minutes ago. I had looked at the same dozen of lines some hours ago but
> not seen the bug. Thank you for insisting there's something wrong.
> 
> For one post, fetchnews would see alt.binaries... is not allowed

ITYM "should."

> on individual.net (PCRE), skip it, check that alt.fan... is allowed,
> issue a GROUP command, receive the 211 reply and try to post. This
> hasn't happened, but I don't know why. A "debugmode=2" debug log (see
> the TROUBLESHOOTING section in README for details) might help shed some
> light on this.

I sent another pair of tests with debugmode=2:
Mar 17 02:37:56 bruce fetchnews[1751]: config: debugmode is 2
Mar 17 02:37:56 bruce fetchnews[1751]: config: link articles in all groups
Mar 17 02:37:56 bruce fetchnews[1751]: config: expire is 30 days
Mar 17 02:37:56 bruce fetchnews[1751]: config: hostname is ID-92747.user.uni-berlin.de
Mar 17 02:37:56 bruce fetchnews[1751]: config: server is news.individual.net
Mar 17 02:37:56 bruce fetchnews[1751]: config: found username for news.individual.net
Mar 17 02:37:56 bruce fetchnews[1751]: config: found password for news.individual.net
Mar 17 02:37:56 bruce fetchnews[1751]: config: only_groups_pcre for news.individual.net is (?!(alt\.binaries|alt\.cmm))
Mar 17 02:37:56 bruce fetchnews[1751]: config: server is news.mel.connect.com.au
Mar 17 02:37:56 bruce fetchnews[1751]: config: server is freenews.netfront.net
Mar 17 02:37:56 bruce fetchnews[1751]: config: nopost for freenews.netfront.net is 1
Mar 17 02:37:56 bruce fetchnews[1751]: config: server is allnews.readfreenews.net
Mar 17 02:37:56 bruce fetchnews[1751]: config: nopost for allnews.readfreenews.net is 1
Mar 17 02:37:56 bruce fetchnews[1751]: config: nntpport is 120
Mar 17 02:37:56 bruce fetchnews[1751]: config: no active file updates for allnews.readfreenews.net
Mar 17 02:37:56 bruce fetchnews[1751]: Core file size: 16777216
Mar 17 02:37:57 bruce fetchnews[1751]: leafnode 1.9.52.rc4: verbosity level is 4, debugmode is 2
Mar 17 02:37:57 bruce fetchnews[1751]: try_lock(timeout=5), fqdn="ID-92747.user.uni-berlin.de"
Mar 17 02:38:04 bruce fetchnews[1751]: <200 The server welcomes acc2-ppp106.mrn.dialup.connect.net.au (210.10.236.234). Authorization required for reading and posting.
Mar 17 02:38:04 bruce fetchnews[1751]: connected to 130.133.1.4:119, reply: 200
Mar 17 02:38:07 bruce fetchnews[1751]: <381 PASS required
Mar 17 02:38:11 bruce fetchnews[1751]: <281 Authentication accepted. (UID=92747)
Mar 17 02:38:11 bruce fetchnews[1751]: >MODE READER
Mar 17 02:38:15 bruce fetchnews[1751]: <200 You are already in this mode. Ignored.
Mar 17 02:38:15 bruce fetchnews[1751]: >GROUP alt.test
Mar 17 02:38:18 bruce fetchnews[1751]: <211 32587 2629046 2814736 alt.test
Mar 17 02:38:18 bruce fetchnews[1751]: >STAT <egjji1-kl1.ln1@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Mar 17 02:38:21 bruce fetchnews[1751]: <430 No such article
Mar 17 02:38:21 bruce fetchnews[1751]: postarticles: trying to post file 1716-1079451374-1 Message-ID <egjji1-kl1.ln1@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Mar 17 02:38:21 bruce fetchnews[1751]: >POST
Mar 17 02:38:25 bruce fetchnews[1751]: <340 Ok, recommended ID <c3771d$23pbj6$1@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Mar 17 02:38:25 bruce fetchnews[1751]: >.
Mar 17 02:38:32 bruce fetchnews[1751]: <441 437 Poison newsgroup
Mar 17 02:38:32 bruce fetchnews[1751]: >STAT <egjji1-kl1.ln1@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Mar 17 02:38:35 bruce fetchnews[1751]: <430 No such article
Mar 17 02:38:35 bruce fetchnews[1751]: postarticles: Article file 1716-1079451374-1 Message-ID <egjji1-kl1.ln1@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> was rejected: "441 437 Poison newsgroup"
Mar 17 02:38:35 bruce fetchnews[1751]: moving file 1716-1079451374-1 to failed.postings
Mar 17 02:38:35 bruce fetchnews[1751]: postarticles: file 1726-1079451375-1: server does not carry Newsgroups: alt.binaries.test,alt.test
Mar 17 02:38:35 bruce fetchnews[1751]: news.individual.net: 0 articles posted.
Mar 17 02:38:35 bruce fetchnews[1751]: >DATE
Mar 17 02:38:39 bruce fetchnews[1751]: <111 20040316153836
Mar 17 02:38:39 bruce fetchnews[1751]: check_date: news.individual.net: server time 1079451516, our time 1079451519
Mar 17 02:38:39 bruce fetchnews[1751]: >QUIT
Mar 17 02:38:45 bruce fetchnews[1751]: <200 news.mel.connect.com.au InterNetNews NNRP server INN 2.2 21-Jan-1999 ready (posting ok).
Mar 17 02:38:45 bruce fetchnews[1751]: connected to 192.189.54.5:119, reply: 200
Mar 17 02:38:45 bruce fetchnews[1751]: >MODE READER
Mar 17 02:38:48 bruce fetchnews[1751]: <200 news.mel.connect.com.au InterNetNews NNRP server INN 2.2 21-Jan-1999 ready (posting ok).
Mar 17 02:38:48 bruce fetchnews[1751]: >GROUP alt.binaries.test
Mar 17 02:38:51 bruce fetchnews[1751]: <211 105303 4176123 4658559 alt.binaries.test
Mar 17 02:38:51 bruce fetchnews[1751]: >STAT <fgjji1-ul1.ln1@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Mar 17 02:38:55 bruce fetchnews[1751]: <430 No such article
Mar 17 02:38:55 bruce fetchnews[1751]: postarticles: trying to post file 1726-1079451375-1 Message-ID <fgjji1-ul1.ln1@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Mar 17 02:38:55 bruce fetchnews[1751]: >POST
Mar 17 02:38:57 bruce fetchnews[1751]: <340 Ok
Mar 17 02:38:57 bruce fetchnews[1751]: >.
Mar 17 02:39:03 bruce fetchnews[1751]: <240 Article posted
Mar 17 02:39:03 bruce fetchnews[1751]: news.mel.connect.com.au: 1 articles posted.
Mar 17 02:39:03 bruce fetchnews[1751]: >DATE
Mar 17 02:39:06 bruce fetchnews[1751]: <111 20040316153903
Mar 17 02:39:06 bruce fetchnews[1751]: check_date: news.mel.connect.com.au: server time 1079451543, our time 1079451546
Mar 17 02:39:06 bruce fetchnews[1751]: >QUIT
Mar 17 02:39:14 bruce fetchnews[1751]: <200 news.netfront.net InterNetNews NNRP server INN 2.3.5 ready (posting ok).
Mar 17 02:39:14 bruce fetchnews[1751]: connected to 202.177.16.121:119, reply: 200
Mar 17 02:39:14 bruce fetchnews[1751]: >MODE READER
Mar 17 02:39:18 bruce fetchnews[1751]: <200 news.netfront.net InterNetNews NNRP server INN 2.3.5 ready (posting ok).
Mar 17 02:39:18 bruce fetchnews[1751]: >DATE
Mar 17 02:39:21 bruce fetchnews[1751]: <111 20040316153918
Mar 17 02:39:21 bruce fetchnews[1751]: check_date: freenews.netfront.net: server time 1079451558, our time 1079451561
Mar 17 02:39:21 bruce fetchnews[1751]: >QUIT
Mar 17 02:39:33 bruce fetchnews[1751]: <201 puce.readfreenews.net NNRP Service Ready - news@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx (no posting).
Mar 17 02:39:33 bruce fetchnews[1751]: connected to 209.98.50.129:120, reply: 201
Mar 17 02:39:33 bruce fetchnews[1751]: >MODE READER
Mar 17 02:39:35 bruce fetchnews[1751]: <201 puce.readfreenews.net NNRP Service Ready - news@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx (no posting).
Mar 17 02:39:35 bruce fetchnews[1751]: >DATE
Mar 17 02:39:37 bruce fetchnews[1751]: <111 20040316153935
Mar 17 02:39:37 bruce fetchnews[1751]: check_date: allnews.readfreenews.net: server time 1079451575, our time 1079451577
Mar 17 02:39:37 bruce fetchnews[1751]: >QUIT

> For the other post, fetchnews would try alt.fan... first, see it is
> allowed on individual.net (PCRE), issue a GROUP command, receive the 211
> reply and try to post.
> 
> > Shouldn't the pcre be applied to all groups in the Newsgroups: header,
> > before attempting to post? That is the problem here, it seems.
> 
> It should, but indeed it isn't. Indeed only the first group in the list
> was tested if it was unmatched.
> 
> HOWEVER, if I fix this issue (and I will because the bug can prevent
> crossposted articles from being posted at all), you will not be able to
> post an article with that group combination any more.

I see you've already added the match_all option I would have requested here.
Thank you.
-- 
Joshua 'bruce' Crawford ... http://www.geocities.com/mortarn

"In questions of science the authority of a thousand is not worth the humble
reasoning of a single individual." -Galileo Galilei

Attachment: pgp00003.pgp
Description: PGP signature

-- 
_______________________________________________
leafnode-list mailing list
leafnode-list@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
http://www.dt.e-technik.uni-dortmund.de/mailman/listinfo/leafnode-list
http://leafnode.sourceforge.net/